Search ...I'm Outta My Mind...

Monday, December 31, 2007

Revealing Aisyah r.a

Aisyah r.a., as we all know, was daughter of Abu- Bakr As- Siddiq r.a., and wife of the great prophet Muhammad s.a.w.

Another well known fact is that Aisyah r.a. married the prophet at a tender age of 7 or 9 years old, at which time she was still playing with her dolls. It was also said that Aisyah stayed with her parents until she reached puberty.

However, some people have wrongly interpreted this fact. As Aisyah was still a kid, they accused the prophet as being a pedophile. I myself have encountered with a few of these nonsense accusations, and I must admit, it was quite difficult for me to answer them.

I mean, by merely saying that the prophet married Aisyah because of a revelation from God is not enough, especially to those non believers. A more solid, reason based idea is needed here to justify this act.

And thankfully, I got the answers I was seeking at this year's Muktamar.

In a talk show during the Muktamar, Imam Yahya Hendi, one of the guest speakers, addressed this matter perfectly.

1. It is wrong to associate the 21st century with that of the 6th. Things that might of been accepted then are no longer accepted now. Cultures change drastically over the course of 1500 years. Even in Malaysia, 50 years ago, people used to get married in their early teenage years.

2. It's also wrong to associate the Arab culture with that of the Americans. Things are different over there with what is over here. An Arab guy would kiss each other when they meet. Doing something similar over here in the US, and you'd be called gay.

3. The third argument may be quite debatable. But here goes. There's actually the idea that maybe Aisyah wasn't 7 or 9 years old when she got married to the Prophet. Her actual age may have been 17/19, 27/29 or maybe even 37/39. In some cultures, people refer to big numbers by just saying the first few digits of the number, with the idea that people would understand what the real number is. For instance, a person would refer to a price of a car as twenty- seven instead of twenty-seven thousand. People may have referred to Aisyah's age with 7/9 with the idea people around her during that time would know her true age.

If so, how would you explain the stories of Aisyah playing with the dolls and what not. Waalahua'lam..

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

I definitely agree with points 1 and 2, and like u said, point 3 is debatable. This is the exact same point I was making to a fellow Malaysian Muslim friend, which is funny because even as we go back a few generations in Malaysia, our grandparents married as soon as they hit puberty. And even to this very day, in many cultures in the middle east and the rest of Asia, this practice is pretty much acceptable as the norm. So we who don't understand that culture should not be commenting too much on it. It's true what they say, people are afraid of things they don't understand.

P.S.: My exams are next week. Pray for me k!

Hubab Al Munzir Asmawi said...

yup!!
Agree with you to every word!

Sang Kelana said...

Salam munzir,

I got an article about this issue. 24 arguments based from Quran and Sunnah, psychology, history, sociology and sexology written by Sheikh Habibur Rahman Kandhalwi. It also point out the false accusation of the age Saidatina Khadijah when married to Prophet Muhammad saw. Message me if you want it.
jzkk.

Sang Kelana said...

oh wait..you can also read it here:

http://www.darulkautsar.com/pemurniansejarah/teks/umreaisyah.htm#A

Anonymous said...

w'salam..
thanks for the heads up on the issue. would really like to have a look at it.
i can't open the link you gave me..

p:s, just wondering who you are.. people don't usualy call me by munzir..hehe..

Sang Kelana said...

oo baru cek balik cni.this is its parent directory:
http://www.darulkautsar.com/pemurniansejarah/pemurniansejarah.htm

jrg pggil munzir eh..then hubab ar slalu.kwn sekelas zaatil mase F5.

Sang Kelana said...

eh...x cukup lg..ish ish..x pndai la sgt coding htm ni..

anyway, go to darulkautsar.com and follow the link pemurnian sejarah islam at the top link of the site.

Hubab Al Munzir Asmawi said...

takpe2, saye lagi bute IT.
thanks anyway..and nice to meet you asl well.

Anonymous said...

hey there!

according to the topic,we have to understand that cultures differ, as what stated by hubab.

when she got married at such age, it didn't mean that she immediately stayed with the Prophet and slept with him. It's more of an act of 'claiming' and legitimizing the partner of one man.

it is only later in life when such things happened.

secondly, how can we explain about children getting married at young age (back in those days)? the same concept applies here.

this is what i personally think, and ideas dug out from conversations. logical thinking-i may be wrong. but then again, the idea of 7 or 9 / 17 or 19 does makes sense too.

at the end of the day, i think it is unfair to compare eye to eye two cultures which are completely different, and conveniently deduce one's own interpretation.

wassalam

Count