First and foremost, I'm not here to condemn Sufism and what it believes, for I know, with the level of knowledge I have, I'm in no position to do so. My intention here is just to give an opinion about this issue. Sorry in advance should I offence anyone.
According to
Wikipedia, however relevant it maybe, Sufism means: a mystic tradition
within Islam and encompasses a diverse range of beliefs and practices dedicated to divine love and the cultivation of the heart.
I was reading a book entitled '
Kisah Rabi'ah Al-
Adawiyah: Sufi
Wanita &
Aramo Cinta Ilahi', which was basically telling the story of the great woman Sufi follower,
Rabi'ah Al-
Adawiyah. Even though I haven't read even half of the book, there were some parts of the book that really caught my attention.
Part 1:
Syah Ni'matullah (another
sufi follower) when asked what
mazhab he was following, replied (in a poetic manner). "
Wahai orang lalai,
mazhab ape
yg mesti kupunyai?
Aku punya mazhad dan ibadah tersendiri,
jauh berbeza dari mazhab Syafi'i dan Abu Hanifah.
Mereka semua menempuh jalan mereka sendiri,
sementara aku menikuti jalan nenek moyangku". What? Following the way of your fore fathers?
And when it is said to them, "Come to what Allah has revealed and to the Messenger," they say, "Sufficient for us is that upon which we found our fathers." Even though their fathers knew nothing, nor were they guided? Al-
Maidah: 104
Part 2: The fact that most Sufis don't marry (including
Rabiah Al-
Adawiyah). Fact is, Islam, unlike other religions is a strong advocate of marriage. The Prophet (
pbuh) has said "there is no celibacy in Islam".
And of His signs is that He created for you from yourselves mates that you may find tranquillity in them; and He placed between you affection and mercy. Indeed in that are signs for a people who give thought. Ar- Rum: 21
Part 3: According to the book, also, how relevant or not it maybe, at her prime, Rabi'ah forgot to love the prophets and condemn
syaitan. In the book,
Rasulullah came to her in her dream and asked her whether or not she loved him. She replied, "
Wahai Rasulullah!
Siapakah gerangan org
yg tidak mencintaimu?
Kecintaanku kpd Allah
tidak memberi kalbu dah hatiku ruang utk mencintai segenap makhluk-
Nya". Like, duh, everyone knows we're supposed to love the
Rasul, and all beings as well.
Part 4: What's with the 'combine with Allah' stuff? A Sufis' desire is to achieve
makrifat, a '
pertemuan dgn Allah'. And sometimes, according to the book, their love for Allah brings them to a thought that they can combine with Allah. Wow! I thought that was something from the Hindu teachings,
moksha (if I'm not mistaken, do correct me if I'm wrong) where once you achieve this stage, you combine with God.
Waalahua'lam...